Martha Washington (The Redbury New York) reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.0
  • Location 4.5
  • Rooms 4.0
  • Service 4.0
  • Value 4.0

867 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 1 out of 5

AVOID, it will cost even if you don’t stay

rebeccakeogh on Aug 18, 2023

Had the hotel booked and paid for, the hotel cancelled and refunded me back less than I paid! This forced me to look for alternative accommodation and pay a higher amount to stay elsewhere. AVOID AT ALL COSTS, it will cost you even if you don’t stay!!!!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 1 out of 5

Hotel could have the decency and called me to tell me the hotel is closed

Steve Z (Florida) on Aug 05, 2023

Hotel is closed, but still allowed me to book my stay. Showed up and the front desk was super sketchy. We can’t book you in, we won’t talk to you, you need to speak to a manager!!! Pretty sure it’s turning into a migrant hotel, but the hotel desk won’t tell you anything!!! Check out the ACE hotel or the Kimpton just down the street!!!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Great hotel

Nicola M on Jul 31, 2023

Fantastic experience with this hotel, I highly recommend. Room was clean (four of us shared a room with 2 double beds), and it was fine for what we needed - a base, just to sleep and get ready. The location was fantastic!! Just be aware of the extra daily fee (wifi, water etc) which is not optional.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Fantastic time

AshleytBillman (Norwich, United Kingdom) on Jul 25, 2023

Hotel is situated very well for sightseeing, restaurants, pubs and clubs. The rooms were very clean and tidy and room service was excellent. Food was excellent and staff were very polite and helpful.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

8 Days at The Redburry!

Jason K on Jun 22, 2023

Where do I start!? So seriously I love this hotel for many reasons and a little put off for small reasons. Good: On our first day checking in me and my partner were totally horribly burnt out and you can see it.... The person checking us in "Chantel" was her name.... Pure gold. She was super kind, friendly, accommodating and definitely had awareness of the situation which is crucial for a client facing role like hers. Location: If you like to walk the location is awesome and we picked it partly for this reason. It's smacked in the middle of anywhere you want to be in NYC, so most Lyft or Uber fairs were from $12-$30 to most anywhere around the city if you don't take the subway. Design: If nothing else The Redburry has awesome style and design is well thought out. I loved it. Not so good: The first room we got the first didn't even have space for the suitcases... the bathroom was literally bigger than the sleeping space..... We upgraded to a Deluxe for the next 7 days. There were small things missing in rooms of a hotel of that caliber that were off putting.... Since I don't like to bother people even if I am paying this was a bit a fuss to have to go down or call room service for slippers, Tooth brush/paste, water.... hotel water.... There was also an added amenities fee if I'm not mistaken but.... I felt there were little to no amenities for this. Staff: Like I said before "Chantel" was a godsend and the fact that it's the only name I remember says a lot ha.... I'd say 90% of the experience with the staff was brilliant and lovely. There was one particular staff member that was not so friendly and made a fuss about us asking for water.... (Note we were staying at this hotel 8 days consecutively)... This attitude I'd expect from a motel or a 7 Days in, but not a Chelsea $200-300night hotel... On that note please put Kettles in the room guys.... Atleast the Deluxe rooms should already have basic things already in the room like I mentioned earlier. Overall I'd say I had a great experience with a few small bumps but it's expected after staying so.many days right? For 1-2 days I'd definitely stay again, but I need to stay for s week or longer I'd suggest staying somewhere else if you don't want to bother staff for small things over and over. Great experience overall!

View All