Sugar Beach Condo reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.0
  • Location 4.5
  • Rooms 4.0
  • Service 4.0
  • Value 4.0

783 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Sugar Beach - fine but

JC505 (Ennetbaden, Switzerland) on Mar 26, 2024

Just not our cup of tea. That being said, the other 12 members in our party loved everything about this place, and that comforted us. Now for us, we hate sleeping with a blowing a/c even on low, but the road noise early morning was just too disturbing. The wind itself was also great, but that is out of the unit’s control. What we miss is that Vacasa cleans out the entire flat so one must bring basic essentials. It truly is a shame what we left or other’s as well that was tossed. I understand that it is a liability issue, but it is truly such a waste and does not fit with our time anymore. Other than this, the unit itself was comfortable and well layed out as the pictures represent. We are not fans of tall bar chairs and tables, but understand as it allows for a view out to the incredible bay and whales and light waves. The location cannot be beat, as it is right in the middle between everything outside of Kihei that you may want to visit. Is it a place we would return to. The price/value and location are very good.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 2 out of 5

VRBO fiasco

Sam K on Mar 11, 2024

VRBO has been the worst channel to book a reservation. The day of arrival I get a missed voicemail that I did not sign a rental agreement. I tried to call back but the “host” is closed. I tried VRBO and they try to call the host but can’t. So now I’m sleeping on the street. Finally after 8:30 pm they get someone to email me the rental agreement for me to sign and then I get my arrival instructions at 9:47 pm. Now getting a receipt to bill my company (business travel) was another headache. Expedia help center sent me to VRBOu, who sent me to the host who were again closed. It took me a few hours to get my receipt.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

One of favorite places to stay

V6955ZHrichards (Soddy Daisy, Tennessee) on Dec 16, 2023

We have stayed at this resort multiple times over the years. It is located on the beach and is the second to last building on the bay before wildlife reserve. It has a nice pool and hot tub. The resort has changed hands since we last stayed and there are some changes in the check in process. Each unit is individually owned and are well kept. Our unit did not have wash cloths, but an owner was talking to another individual at the hot tub about white wash cloths and mascara permanently staining them so he had purchased black wash cloths. It is an older building, bathroom is smaller than most newer places, but would stay there again.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Unit 326 was perfect!!

helenwZ7392LV on Nov 23, 2023

This unit was managed by Ali'i Resorts and they were so helpful and accommodating. The unit had nice furnishings, a super comfortable bed, and a well stocked kitchen. Everything worked perfectly, the lanai overlooked the beach, and the resort is central to everything. The grounds are well kept with lots of lawn chairs and the pool area is clean, nice and has a restroom. We had an amazing tlme and honestly have no complaints. Found supplies we didn't expect, beach towels and nice Tommy Bahama beach chairs and lots of bath towels! If we return Maui, we eill book this unit agalin.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 3 out of 5

Average for price. May rent again if different unit.

Pioneer535828 on Nov 10, 2023

Nice resort older condo complex but they try to keep clean. Depending on which unit you rent, many of the interiors have been nicely remodeled however you want to be sure to get a mainly ocean view or you will be staring directly across other building unit interiors. At the beach, there is not one shade structure to block sun so be certain your rental provides a beach umbrella if is that is important to you.

View All