Buffalo Mountain Lodge reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.1
  • Location 4.3
  • Rooms 3.9
  • Service 4.1
  • Value 3.7

3039 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Great stay

das1234 (Melbourne, Australia) on Jan 24, 2026

Had a great stay here, staff were friendly and helpful. The room was comfortable and enjoyed the welcome gift and card and the other gift during the stay, that was a great touch. We stayed here as it was out of town, so it was very quite even with being on the road. Car parking is limited, but was able to find a space near our room, so its not a problem. It was nice to receive messages during the stay to let us know what was going on around the property. Overall, we enjoyed our stay, the place is comfortable and clean and has everything you need, thank you.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Wonderful stay!

Ken R on Jan 21, 2026

Beautiful location and lovely room with wood fireplace. Attended a wine pairing dinner hosted in the O'Connor house, 100% recommended!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 2 out of 5

Look elsewhere.

Connor L on Jan 20, 2026

Poor service, poor location. Rooms are nice, but difficult to get to given the parking lots congestion and maintenance (ice everywhere, all week). Amenities are difficult to access and lackluster. The hot tub is nice, but not very hot. Our one attempt at eating at The Prow was awful, and we never got served after nearly an hour at a table. Gym area was small and smelt horrible. Housekeeping often left items in our room, and wore their outside snow and sand-covered shoes inside, making the space dirtier than before. I'd recommend looking for a stay in town, as Buffalo Mountain Lodge is not worth the drive up the hill.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Great hotel

Catherine C (Chester, United Kingdom) on Jan 18, 2026

A lovely hotel with really friendly and helpful staff. I would certainly recommend staying here. The hot tub and restaurant were a great addition too.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Good stay & a nice location

Kanishka R on Jan 10, 2026

Had a good stay at the Buffalo mountain lodge. Friendly staff, great location. Rooms were clean they cleaned everyday and the couple of chairs/couch was comfortable. Bathroom looked modern and was clean. Only negative thing is, stayed in a downstairs room & can hear all the walking, pulling chairs, rolling luggage etc. from upstairs room, it can be very disturbing. Had breakfast at the PROW, service was good & fast with friendly staff. Breakfast reservations recommended.

View All