Comfort Suites Paradise Island reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.1
  • Location 4.6
  • Rooms 3.8
  • Service 4.1
  • Value 4.2

3420 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Amazing staff, perfect location & great stay!

StellarFairy (Valley Stream, New York) on Oct 11, 2026

We had a great stay! The staff was exceptionally friendly and welcomed us right away. Very convenient location and the free breakfast is a plus. The best part is you get free daily access to Atlantis which was amazing!! This is the best value on Paradise Island.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 1 out of 5

Budget Hotel at best, Beware!!!!!

Sunshine306585 on Oct 09, 2026

This was a horrible experience, the rooms had a strong mold like smell, we changed rooms immediately but the next room still had the smell just not as strong the floors were cracked and the room was not cleaned well. We noticed a pretzel on the floor by the bed when we first got into the room and after 3 days of house keeping it was still on the floor, I would not stay here again. There were also problems with the water. Yes you get the passes for Atlantis and free breakfast but it is not worth it, it’s a 2 star hotel so keep that in mind when booking. Beware this is not a nice place to stay!!!!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 3 out of 5

Average Experience

mc f on Oct 03, 2026

The location was very convenient for our purpose. We arrived approximately 4:00pm. The grounds of the hotel is well kept and beautiful. Check-in went well. Instructions to find our room (take 1st left, then second left) didn't prepare us for the maze we had to through to reach our room. The corridors and room had a mold like smell and gave the sense of unused space. Preparation of the room was incomplete as we met the door ajar and the comforter sitting atop the bathroom sink. The room dynamics is strange with the kitchen amenities right next to the bed to include the sink and small refrigerator. The furniture is dated. The AC was very noisy and not super cold. The water pressure in the bath was low and the bathroom sink was spouting water all over the countertop when opened. The trampling overhead was disconcerting. The Staff was very courteous and friendly. The Complimentary Breakfast was good. I felt the options were good (toast, eggs, bacon, juice, tea, coffee, potatoes, sausage links, assorted pastries, yogurt, cereal, boiled eggs, fruit. We had reason to request accommodation for one additional night and we were accommodated without any difficulty. Anthony's within 5 minutes walking distance was a plus. Extremely great customer service, good food reasonably priced. I can't honestly indicate I would book Comfort Suites again.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Great experience

Lacalif2g (Phoenix, Arizona) on Oct 02, 2026

I had a fabulous time here. No complaints. The front staff was efficient and friendly. The rooms were spacious and clean. The hotel is across the street from Atlantis and the use of its facilities was amazing. It's also near the bridge, so it you're up to it, it's a Nike walk to Potters Cay for authentic Bahamian food. It's also close to downtown and most Nassau tourist spots. They offered a daily continental breakfast which was filling. I would recommend and stay again.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Best experience

Stalksjulisha1 on Sep 07, 2026

Loved our stay, not to mention the easy check in and warm welcome from the front desk,.BIG UP JAMAL ONE LOVE ?? ???? FROM JAMAICA

View All