Bay Gardens Hotel reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.4
  • Location 4.3
  • Rooms 4.0
  • Service 4.3
  • Value 4.2

2025 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

A Comfortable and Memorable Stay

camper739391651 on May 05, 2026

We had a wonderful stay! The surroundings were beautiful, the room was spotless, and the location was excellent. Each morning we enjoyed a delicious breakfast, which was a great start to the day. A special thank you to the receptionist and housekeeper, who were both knowledgeable, attentive, and quick to address any concerns, they truly added value to our experience.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

A little piece of paradise

Janette W (Lincolnshire, United Kingdom) on Apr 19, 2026

Recently returned from a two week stay at the Bay Gardens. Hotel met our expectations; we wanted a small hotel centrally located We knew it did not have beach access but this was not a problem with using the free shuttle bus service that ran every hour between there and the sister hotel Bay Gardens Beach Resort and Spa. We were met in Reception by wonderful, friendly staff and a glass of rum punch on arrival. Very welcome after a long flight from the UK. The first night took a little getting used to as what we thought was a squeeky air con unit was in fact the whistling tree frogs that serenade you all night long, every night. But you get used to it. The meals were good, if a little repetitive and the vegetarian option was limited. We ate at the sister hotel a few times as well as going to local restaurants during our time there, just for a change. Service could be slow but this is part of the culture of the Caribbean with a more laid back approach than what we are used to in the UK. Having said that all the staff, whether it be front of desk, bar, waiting, gardeners, chefs were all hard working and very accommodating and always service with a smile and very helpful. There was entertainment at the hotel on some nights and the guy who played and sang was really good. Also, must mention Silesa who helped with our luggage and sang beautifully (despite what my husband said to keep winding her up!!). There are a few cats (feral) that wander around but they are friendly. So much so, that twice we found one on the bed at 3 am after it had climbed up to our first floor balcony. From then on we made sure we only left it ajar a couple of inches during the night. I went for a few complimentary massages (as we were all inclusive) at the sister hotel, Bay Gardens Beach Resort and Spa whilst on holiday and must mention both Beverley and Nadia who did the most amazing massages. You were simply the best ladies! All in all, no complaints, a wonderful holiday on the most beautiful island, learned a lot about the culture and husband managed to track down some information on his ancestry. We shall certainly return, hopefully next year. We went on a number of excursions whilst there and would recommend the snorkling and cruise, volcanic mud baths and waterfall, independent tour of St Lucia with trip around the market in Castries, the capital, and whale and dolphin watching, although sadly they did not appear that day but we saw a number of flying fish and brown booby birds (yes, honestly!). A fabulous island, people and a hotel that felt like home. For the first time ever we didn't want to return back to UK from a holiday that we had both enjoyed so much. So much so, we even started looking at buying a property there and enjoying our retirement in the sun!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Fabulous Stay and Lovely Staff

Swimmerja (Jamaica) on Apr 15, 2026

Fantastic staff and amazing hotel. From the day we arrived it was a great experience. Dinner was amazing especially with what was offered. Extremely tasty and presentation was 5 star restaurant quality. Unbeatable location for getting around Rodney Bay as well as rooms are completely modern. Loved my stay and would recommend.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 2 out of 5

Will not recommend

Akillia S on Apr 03, 2026

Poor in everything Food, service n bfast.. upkeeping of inn n hotel Only good thing is... it's centralized to most night life n restaurants

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Our tropical home away from home

Jeremy P (Victoria, Canada) on Mar 28, 2026

The staff at Bay Gardens truly goes above and beyond to look after their guests while keeping the properties looking sharp. It has become our genuine home away from home, and we find ourselves returning time and time again. The beach amenities available to all guests—it makes the experience so seamless and enjoyable. We want to extend a huge thank you to the entire team for their incredible hospitality, including: • The welcoming Front Desk attendants • The hardworking restaurant breakfast crew • The attentive beach security • The helpful Wibit crew We truly appreciate the effort everyone puts in to make each stay special. We can't wait to come back!

View All