TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Pleasantly surprised with both the room and staff. The room was spacious, loved the soaking tub. Friendly and attentive staff. Can’t beat the location. One other plus you might not think about unless you stay at a lot of NYC hotels is , the elevators are fast!

Very clean hotel, prompt service and easy check in / check out procedure. The housekeeping was excellent, providing anything we asked for anytime without any hassle at all, extra pillows and towels made our stay so much nicer.

Only con is that the room is quite small. Other than that everything is perfect: location, staff, design, overall cleanness and even a surprising grab and go breakfast!! Will definitely go back again!

PRICE is a bit steep for what you receive. You pay for a facility fee at the end of the stay in addition to the room. We got a cheaper, and we think, better hotel downtown. LOCATION is excellent close to 5th Avenue etc., but a bit noisy with the traffic right outside the hotel. Luckily, it usually became quieter at night. BREAKFAST consisted mainly of pastries and some fruit. It was difficult to eat healthy here for breakfast. STAFF were nice. ROOMS were big, but could use a bit refurbishment. Would have loved if they had a fridge in the room.

My husband and I had to find a last minute hotel in the Midtown East area of New York. The majority of the places were over budget but then I discovered Hotel 57. I almost passed up on it because we went to the room with a mini fridge and it was not listed under amenities. We bought the king junior suite and were surprised at how large the room was - especially for New York standards. The bed was incredibly comfy. The room was spotless. And we had a mini fridge! (It’s the small things that count.) I was able to get a robe on request which as my husband pointed out, was nicer than my robe at home. Continental breakfast was exactly that - no more, no less. (I saw reviews complaining about there only being pastries, fruit, and coffee which really had me shaking my head at. That literally is the typical continental breakfast. This saved me from going out and buying a crossiant and coffee. The location of the hotel was another big bonus. Everywhere we needed to go was less than 15 minutes to walk to. My husband and I already decided, when we return to Manhattan, we definitely will stay here again.