Renaissance Hotel 57 reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.0 Very Good

  • Cleanliness 4.3
  • Location 4.6
  • Rooms 3.7
  • Service 4.1
  • Value 3.7

2105 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Well located for my needs

danwV8742JL (Thornhill, Canada) on Dec 08, 2025

The East Side location was perfect for this trip and the hotel was as I expected. It is definitely a "boutique" hotel and a bit dated. However, the room was clean, bed extremely comfortable, and staff very friendly!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Just departed from the hotel after a very nice stay.

Companion08514799960 on Nov 28, 2025

Just departed from the hotel after a very nice stay. When we checked in, we were mistakenly allocated a room with just one bed, but this wasn’t the hotel’s fault but the booking agent.The lady at reception handled it brilliantly and resolved the issue extremely quickly. The beds were very comfortable and the pillows were amazing! Before arriving, I had read some worrying reviews online and wasn’t sure what to expect, but honestly, everything was clean and well maintained. Please don’t be put off by some of the negative reviews. Most of the staff were wonderful,friendly, helpful, and welcoming. However, I do have to mention that one particular receptionist really let the team down. We accidentally locked ourselves out of the room while popping next door and went to reception for help. She repeatedly asked for ID, which of course was in the room. This went on for a couple of minutes before she finally called upstairs to get someone to come to the room to confirm who we were by checking passports.I completely understand the importance of security, but her attitude came across as rude and unreasonable, especially considering she’d seen us coming and going every day and never once acknowledged us the way her colleagues did. Aside from that one encounter, everything else was great. Overall, a pleasant stay and would return.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Don't Understand the Poor Reviews

dkberman (Washington DC, District of Columbia) on Nov 17, 2025

My experience was fine. Room was small but functional. Clean and everything worked fine. Coffee maker in the cupboard, but why would you....Friendly font desk. Only issue which is not their fault, is location is sort of no man's land between Times Square and the Park, but I think that's also reflected in the rates. Near 5th Ave. if that's what you enjoy. I would not hesitate to recommend.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Welcome Home!

Sam B on Nov 12, 2025

Eric was awesome and helped me check-in early!!! The whole staff was incredibly welcoming, like they were greeting an old friend! Great way to start my stay!!!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 1 out of 5

Avoid this dump

Robert S on Oct 16, 2025

This place is a dump. Black water came out of the tap. Was told “we don’t provide waters for rooms at this time. O coffe maker in room. And they charged me $8 for a small parcel. Save you self the trouble. There are better place at better cost.

View All