TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

We stayed at Atlantis Paradise Island for five nights in multiple premium ocean-view suites at the Reef (20th and 21st floors)—one 1-bedroom and one 2-bedroom—with a total stay cost close to $20,000. We chose these accommodations expecting a luxury experience consistent with the pricing. On the first evening, we were not impacted only because we arrived late. Beginning the following day, however, we experienced repeated hot-water failures during peak shower hours (approximately 4–5pm) for four consecutive days. This issue was reported multiple times throughout the stay. As the stay progressed, the situation became increasingly disruptive: * Several members of our party had to go to the spa just to take a warm shower * We were advised by staff that we could use the transit lounge showers, which is not an acceptable workaround for guests staying in premium suites * Hot water did not reliably return until the morning of our departure, requiring us to check out late so all six of us could shower before leaving * Staff at the spa told us that the same hot-water issue occurred over Thanksgiving, pointing to a known, recurring capacity issue, not an isolated incident Compounding the issue, we were told multiple times that a manager would call us to discuss the situation, yet no call ever occurred. The lack of follow-through added to the overall frustration. Hot water is not a luxury amenity—it is a basic expectation. At nearly $5,000 per night, and while staying in premium ocean-view suites on the 20th and 21st floors of the Reef, guests should not have to plan their day around where they can find a warm shower. While the resort ultimately refunded $3,000, this adjustment did not adequately reflect: * The duration of the issue (4 of 5 days) * The disruption to a six-person traveling party * The premium accommodations booked * The ultra-premium rates charged * The apparent prior awareness of similar failures * The lack of management engagement despite repeated assurances Atlantis has impressive grounds and amenities, but until core infrastructure reliability and guest-service accountability are addressed, it does not consistently deliver an experience that justifies its pricing. I would welcome outreach from resort management to understand what concrete corrective actions are being taken to prevent this from happening to future guests.

The amount they will hold and charge on your card varies significantly from what is explained . The website room explains room types that aren’t even available. Without even spending half of the original hold amount for incidentals they randomly charged more to my card. Ryan at the front desk lied about my accommodation and then called the day before checkout to say he was charging my card another 1k for my room type I never asked for. I waited 5 hours just to check in on day one because my room wasn’t ready.

Nobody seemed happy to work there. Very expensive, Food outrageous cost. Slides getting run down. Much better place several years ago. Will not go back again.

Whilst I have loved going to the reef many times in the past, things seem to have gone downhill. Staff friendliness (except housekeeping who were great), room view (worst we have had), room and water smell (made it undrinkable and even the shower smelled), water park water temperature was cold. But beach beds at the reef were a nice upgrade from the past, even though many of them were still broken.

I honestly loved staying at The Reef more than I expected to. From the moment we checked in, it just felt calm in a good way. After walking through the busier parts of Atlantis, coming back to The Reef felt like a relief every single time. It’s quieter, more relaxed, and just easier to breathe there. The room was great — big, comfortable, and actually felt like somewhere you could live for a few days instead of just crash at night. The ocean view was unreal, especially in the morning. Sitting on the balcony and taking in that view was one of my favorite parts of the trip. The beach by The Reef is also underrated. It’s not as chaotic as some of the other areas, way less crowded, and perfect if you just want to swim, walk along the shore, or do absolutely nothing for a while. Even though it feels peaceful, everything is still super close — Aquaventure, the restaurants, the marina — you’re never far from anything. Staff were friendly without being overbearing, and everything felt clean and well taken care of. It just felt… easy. Like nothing was stressful or annoying, which is exactly what you want on vacation.