Secrets St. James Montego Bay reviews

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

4.5 Excellent

  • Cleanliness 4.5
  • Location 4.6
  • Rooms 4.4
  • Service 4.4
  • Value 4.2

10274 TripAdvisor reviews

TripAdvisor users rated this property 4 out of 5

Great people and beautiful grounds! Really enjoyed the live music walking up to breakfast. Very talented young ladies.

Tamara W (Flowery Branch, Georgia) on May 17, 2025

Erika and Ghenelle (lobby bar) were GREAT! AWESOME drinks and lots of laughs. Shanice ( pool cocktail waitress) did a FANTASTIC Mai Tai and was so friendly. She should be promoted to bartender. She knows her stuff! Janelle ( pool cocktail waitress in training) took WONDERFUL care of us on our pool day checking on us several times .Sasha K (piano bar waitress) was LOVELY to talk to and did her job with excellence going above and beyond. Roberta and Kendrea (coffee bar) knew my order when I walked up! I saw them twice a day because there coffee and ice cream were AWESOME! Nicola ( housekeeping) took care of our room with EXCELLENCE and a beautiful smile. Conrad and Hopeton( bell hops) greeted us with smiles and fist bumps our whole trip. GREAT FIRST IMPRESSION! Great time at the piano bar! Both gentlemen that played there were VERY TALENTED! Please fix/tune your piano. The sound systems also need work ( very distorted) Disorganization was frustrating for scheduling. Hanging schedules, the app, and staff were all telling us different things which made it difficult to plan your day/ night.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Secrets St. James wedding/honeymoon

Tanya H on May 15, 2025

St.James was so beautiful. The beaches are kept clean and the wait staff make sure your taken care of. Our Butler's made sure we needed nothing our entire stay by bringing us jerk chicken from the cart which was my favorite food the whole time and drinks by pool or beach never stopped. We were married on the beach while there and it was amazing with the sunset in the background! If you never been to Jamaica this is the place to go!!

TripAdvisor users rated this property 2 out of 5

Great vacation, until food poisoning! Avoid this resort!

talvis0321 (Richmond, Virginia) on May 12, 2025

This was our 2nd trip to Secrets St James. We were so excited to return. Stayed preferred ocean view room via St James side (non butler). Room was fine, outdated but was clean. We enjoyed our first couple of days until my husband came down with severe food poisoning. The rest of the trip he was bedside unable to move, eat etc. We didnt see the nurse on site as he wanted to travel home to US for doctors. We have been home for 2 days and still the same status health wise. We marked this down to three different items he ate that I didnt- the preferred snacks (sushi- looked gross and smelled fishy), lamb at Breathless rooftop or the Tartar at Bordaux. This ruined our trip and when mentioned to the staff and at check out, no one seemed to have cared. In addition, we had an excursion booked through Amstar that they would not refund us for unless he saw a Dr (which would have led to going to a Jamaican hospital. NO THANK YOU)! I am sorry, but his health is more important and we would not make up him being sick! Outside of the food poisoning, beware the chair game is unreal. The only way to really get good chairs is with a butler reserving them for you. It was unreal how many blocked chairs by the butlers happened every day and alot of times no one sat in them. This is one of the only Secrets resorts out of many we have visited where this has been the case. On a positive- beautiful sunets and good entertainment.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 1 out of 5

Save your money and stay somewhere else.

Wayne B on May 11, 2025

Poor reception process, very dated and run down. Housekeeping, while friendly is understaffed and late (after 4pm) or may be skipped entirely. Restaurants were okay but service was extremely slow at time even though it was not particularly busy.

TripAdvisor users rated this property 5 out of 5

Our Jamaica ???? trip

wcfamily2023 on May 08, 2025

We spent 10 days in Jamaica. We stayed at Secrets St James and had a fabulous time there. Zoya (a UVC representative) met us at checkin. She was fabulous and friendly and helped us out all week long. Santanya kept our room tidy and clean each day and helped us out when we needed it restocked with things. Kerry Anne Served us each day the at the preferred club pool with her joyful and happy spirit!! Every evening we’d visit the Coco Cafe for coffee and rum and raisin icecream with rum cream and Tanika would serve us with a friendly and eager attitude. Shenea served us twice at breathless altitude rooftop restaurant which was by far the best food and view and meal experience !! All in all an amazing time at Secrets St James.

View All